Lady Gaga, Fame Monster or Positive Role Model?

Also be sure to read part one of this post here Parental/Teen Conversations

There’s no doubt that some of Gaga’s antics, such as wearing meat and being painted with blood is not something that parents want to highlight to their teens. There’s also no doubt that she is coming out of left field much of the time. Because some of her songs depict lyrics of partying and no-strings attached sex, many parents most likely wish she would just go away. As a parent, you may love her or you may hate her. One thing is certain these days though, is you can’t avoid her. The reality is that she is one of the most modern teen influencers today, so parents need to understand some of her influential messages as well as choose to focus on her positive actions.

For one thing, Lady Gaga works hard and has done so since she was a toddler. She was playing the piano at the age of five and was writing songs by the time she was 13. She’s even written songs for the likes of Akon and Britney Spears. She started performing at open mike events at the age of 14. Raised as a Roman Catholic, she threw herself into high school musicals, portraying lead roles. She attended Tisch School of Arts in New York University, where she wrote an 80-page thesis paper on pop artist and studied art, music and socio-religion. Gaga did end up dropping out in the second semester of her sophomore year, but only to dedicate herself to her musical career. She’s one of the few pop artists that writes her own songs, plays her own instruments and sings live.

Another prominent Gaga message that parents should be aware of is in her position of choosing to abstain from sex. In making this choice, she is hoping to influence her young fans to follow suit. She wants her fans to focus on strength and individuality rather than sexual activity. She is urging people to stay safe in sexual relationships and even sometimes passes out free condoms at her concerts.

It’s true that Gaga’s fashion sense is unconventional. But on the other hand, she is demonstrating individuality. Some say that her fishnet stockings, quirky sunglasses and boots make her look like a hooker, but she isn’t showing her most intimate parts. She has been criticized in some circles for her bikini bottoms and leotards as being “slutty”, but do these same people blink an eye when Britney Spears, Beyonce or Rhianna dress the same?

Gaga is all about elevating pop music to an art form. She’s a serious artist and business woman, who’s also concerned about her fans. She embraces her role model status and her femininity. She wants to be a good role model and have a strong connection with her fans. More than that though is her desire to have her fans connect with each other. There in lies the importance of teen influencers.

Philanthropy

Although parents may question some of Lady Gaga’s performance antics, she has earned a spot in the philanthropy world. Parents striking up conversations with their teens or tweens should consider these social topics in their discussions. Gaga has supported numerous humanitarianism works and charities. For example, when the earthquake in Haiti hit in 2010, Gaga held a specific concert dedicated to Haiti’s reconstruction relief fund. All the revenue received from the concert as well as all profits from Gaga’s online store sales for that day were given to the fund. All-in-all, it’s estimated that approximately a half of a million dollars were collected for that relief fund.

In addition, Gaga has made it a focus to educate young women about the risks of AIDS and HIV. In collaboration with MAC Cosmetics and Cindi Lauper, a Viva Glam lipstick line was launched to help the HIV and AIDS awareness cause. All net proceeds from the campaign were donated to prevent AIDS and HIV worldwide.

 

Privacy ProtectionTrial


Gay Community Followers

There’s no doubt that a majority of Gaga’s fans are teens and tweens, with many being girls. However, a large group of Lady Gaga’s followers are from the gay community. In fact, Lady Gaga has indicated much of her initial success of becoming a mainstream artist was due to the support of her gay fans. Today, she is considered to be a growing gay icon. Gaga revealed that her popular song “Poker Face” is about her bisexuality. She’s also an advocate for repeal the United States military “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy and a supporter of voting for legislation that would repeal it. The Advocate, a lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender magazine, says that Gaga has become a “real fierce advocate” for lesbians and gays.

Food for thought

Lady Gaga isn’t seen pole dancing on stage like a young Miley Cyrus, she’s not being arrested for being intoxicated while driving, she’s not being jailed for snorting cocaine, nor is she posing nude in Playboy. What she is doing is writing her own award-winning songs, performing in award winning videos, winning fashion awards and just plain working hard at her craft. Not to mention, she is providing much needed financial support for others in need. Isn’t this what all parents want of their children  — to work hard and be successful at something they are passionate about?

 Also be sure to read part one of this post here

  • Pingback: Born This Way- Lady Gaga’s Leadership and Influence on Teens

  • http://www.standingonmountains.wordpress.com Nymfa

    Thanks for this balanced post! Honestly, I didn’t know about this few good things about Lady Gaga.

    • http://twitter.com/socially_active Amy Kelly

      Glad you liked it Nymfa.

  • Pingback: Egypt’s Revolution and America’s Youth

  • George

    Thank you for the article. I think Lady Gaga is not a negative character, it’s just her public image!!!! I was greatly impressed with her last interview which I downloaded from http://www.torrentoff.com She says that she is indifferent to people’s sorrow in Japan and wants to donate 1.5 million dollars for them to cope with zynga and aftermath of eathquake and tzunami.

  • Slexy_mastera_9887

    I had no idea, but this really opens my eyes to her, I aprechiated what shes done ya know? But when I whatched the good mourning america show an they asked her about if she enjoys being famous and everything when she said oh well Im a normale person when I get home I did’nt really believe it ya know? But know I feel a little bit better being Gaga for the Lady!
    From a Teen,
    Enjoying this repoty.

    • http://twitter.com/socially_active Amy Kelly

       Thanks for your input, glad you enjoyed the article.

  • Greatest Eva

    Lady Gaga is a Pop culture icon best known for her outrageous
    outfits, edgy personality, or her wacky lyrics. She repeatedly talks about
    drinking and sex in most, if not all of her songs. This article, written by
    Elizabeth M. supports the idea that Lady Gaga is a positive role model for
    teens and tweens. However, every time you see the icon on television it is for
    a negative reason. She is constantly coming up with new ways to publicize
    herself like when she wore an outfit made entirely of meat to the MTV Music
    Video Awards, or when she arrived at the Grammy’s in an egg. Lady Gaga is not a
    good role model for teens and tweens because her adult themed lyrics and over
    the top partyer personality does not portray the positive values that the
    younger audience should be influenced by.

    In the Article, Elizabeth uses a fallacy in reasoning when
    she says, “She wants her fans to focus on strength and individuality rather
    than sexual activity”. That statement may be true, but if you listen to any one
    of Lady Gaga’s songs, you will find that it is very hard to believe. She is
    constantly singing about drinking, partying, and having sex. She has lyrics
    such as, “Our hair is perfect, while we’re all getting shit wrecked, it’s
    automatic, honey but we got no money” (Beautiful, Dirty, rich), or “I’ll get
    him hot, show him what I’ve got” (Poker face). Her lyrics are suggestive and
    they do not support Elizabeth’s claim.

    A role model is defined as, “a person whose behavior,
    example, or success is or can be emulated by others, especially by younger
    people” (dictionary.com).  From this
    definition, we can conclude that Lady Gaga is in no way entitled to be a role
    model for teens and tweens. She has an over the top edgy personality that should
    not be emulated by anybody. She wears extremely unique almost provocative
    outfits ranging from a dress made of meat, to bubble wrap. She even showed up
    to the Grammy’s inside of an egg! Lady Gaga is a fame monster and should never
    be considered a role model.

     Lady Gaga has a rough
    background filled with illegal substance such as cocaine, ecstasy, and
    marijuana. In an interview with Howard Stern and Lady Gaga, Stern said, “When
    you talk about getting high, I mean, you were doing some hard core drugs, you
    were into coke and you loved Ecstasy so much” (Serpe). Gaga agreed and later
    admitted to smoking pot the day of the interview. In Elizabeth’s article in
    favor of Lady Gaga being a role model, she wrote, “she’s not being arrested for
    being intoxicated while driving, she’s not being jailed for snorting cocaine,
    nor is she posing nude in Playboy.” This is a fallacy of appeal. While it is
    true that Gaga has not yet done any of these things, she has admitted to
    snorting cocaine as well as using other illegal drugs.  Lady Gaga should not be a role model for teens
    because of her history with drugs and alcohol.

    Lady Gaga is not a good role model for teens and tweens
    because her adult themed lyrics and over the top partyer personality does not
    portray the positive values that the younger audience should be influenced by.
    Gaga’s Lyrics glamorize drinking, partying, and sex. Lady Gaga has a crazy
    personality and uses illegal drugs such as cocaine ecstasy, and marijuana. Lady
    Gaga should not be considered a role model because her lifestyle does not
    reflect that of which teens and tweens should be influenced by. 

    • http://twitter.com/socially_active Amy Kelly

       Greatest Eva, thanks for your input and can see you researched your stuff on Lady Gaga, as parents we should certainly inform ourselves of pop icons who are influencing our teens and tweens, as whether we like it or not Lady Gaga does influence our teens and tweens, I think Elizebeth does a good job of informing us that there are some negative images Lady Gaga portrays, but we should also know some of the positive thing she does, and speak to our teens and tweens about them.

  • Mojpoj

     Before you tell parents that Ms. Germonatta is someone their teens should look up to you need to make sure you have ALL the facts.  Read this article about her interview on 60 minutes.  You either haven’t seen it or aren’t telling the whole truth.  http://www.starpulse.com/news/index.php/2011/02/14/lady_gaga_admits_to_heavy_drug_use_on_

    • http://twitter.com/socially_active Amy Kelly

       Thanks for your input, I read that article, and understand where you are coming from there are a lot of negative things Lady Gaga does, but like with all human beings there are two sides, Elizabeth in this article is pointing out some of her positives, and how parents can speak to their kids about these, as Lady Gaga whether we like it or not influences teens and tweens today.

  • Bboy

    Seriously?? This article has an obvious lack of objectivity. The influence of a singer doesn’t come from what she says during an interview but from her music , the lyrics and her music videos .
    And now what kind of lyrics are lady gaga’s ??
    Just take a look at lovegame : “Let’s have some fun, this beat is sick

    I wanna take a ride on your disco stick” ,
    ” I’m on a mission

    And it involves some heavy touching, yeah

    You’ve indicated your interest

    I’m educated in sex, yes

    And now I want it bad, want it bad

    A lovegame, a lovegame” , ”

    I can see you staring there from across the block

    With a smile on your mouth and your hand on your huh

    The story of us, it always starts the same

    With a boy and a girl and a huh and a game

    And a game (huh)

    And a game (huh)

    And a game (huh)

    A lovegame!”

    What a beautiful teaching for kids! Love is about having sex for fun and considering the partner has an pleasur provider object (Gaga had explained that the term ‘disco stick’ is a euphemism for a penis and was inspired by her sexual attraction with a stranger at a night club.)

    In Telephone , an example of lady gaga’s video , Beyonce and herself use sex has a mean to use and deceive people , people who are at the end killed .

    But yeah , lady gaga is an example for youth .